How We Coach, Part 2 of 10
How We Learn Where You Are Before We Write Your Training

The short answer: Before we can decide how much training you can absorb, we have to know where you are: what you have really been doing, how your week works, where your fitness is strong and where it is fragile, and how you respond to stress. In StressLogic we call this Evaluate, and we come back to it every week. This article explains what we look at, why each piece matters, and how evaluation set the direction for Graham Lloyd, Ben Creswick and Katy Walmsley.
Why "where am I right now?" is harder than it sounds
Most athletes can tell you their goal race and their best week of training. Far fewer can tell you their real average over the last six weeks, or which of their sports is carrying the load and which is quietly behind. That isn't a failing. Memory keeps the big weeks and drops the quiet ones, and a busy life blurs the rest.
The trouble is that every coaching decision after this point depends on the starting picture. If we start from the best remembered week, the first block is too big and the athlete spends a month digging out. If we start from the goal race alone, a sport that isn't ready gets asked for race specific work it can't hold. If we miss how much life stress the athlete is carrying, the weekly load is set for someone with an empty calendar.
So the question here is simple to ask and takes care to answer: what is actually true for you right now, in each sport and in your life? The rest of this article is how we answer it.
How plans usually start, and where that runs out
A common way to start training is to pick the race, count back the weeks and drop into the matching week of a plan. It is quick, and for an athlete whose recent training already matches the plan it can work.
The limit shows up for everyone else. Two people can race the same 70.3 on the same day and need completely different weeks to get there. One has years of running in their legs and a demanding job. Another is strong on the bike and hasn't run in months. A plan that starts both at the same week is wrong for at least one of them, and usually the error only shows up weeks later as a stalled run, a sore tendon or a block that never seems to land.
Evaluation puts the athlete first and the calendar second. We still count back from the race, and the race still shapes the plan. We just do it after we know who is going to do the training.
What we ask when you join, and why each answer matters
Every new athlete fills in one intake. Each question is there because it changes a decision.
- Your sport and background. What you race and how long you have trained tells us how much your body has already adapted, and which sport is likely to be the most fragile.
- Your devices and units. Whether you train with heart rate, power or both decides how we write your targets.
- Your real schedule. Which days you can train, which day you take off, which days can hold a long session, whether you can double up and how much time you have. A plan that ignores this gets missed, and missed sessions are the most common reason a build stalls.
- Your races. What you are aiming at and when, so we can mark which races matter most and set the time we have to build.
- Your preferences. The sessions you enjoy, the ones you dread, and how you like to strength train. An athlete who dreads a session finds reasons to skip it.
One to one athletes also tell us about their goals, their race history, their life load, any recent test results and their recent training files. They answer a short set of mindset questions too, which help us decide how to talk with each athlete and how to explain the training to them.
Why your training history wins over the intake
Then we look at what you have actually done. If you have training history in TrainingPeaks, we rebuild the last six weeks of load the same way we will track it from now on. When the history and the intake disagree, the history wins.
This matters because your fitness today is the result of those weeks, and the next block has to start from it. Starting above it is the fastest way to stack fatigue in the first month. Starting well below it wastes fitness you have already earned.
Your first week with us is a gentle introduction, built from the hours you told us you have and guided by effort and heart rate. It lets us see how you move through a normal week before we ask anything hard. Your second week is usually a test week. We test Critical Power on the bike and Critical Speed on the run and in the pool, with easy days between the tests. Athletes who come in with plenty of recent training data can test in their first week. Strength starts once testing is done. Testing gives every zone a starting point, and we read each result against what your training and your comments tell us.
Reading your fitness one sport at a time
We track fitness separately for bike and run, because one can be well built while the other is fragile, and a single total hides the difference. An athlete with a big bike and a small run can show a healthy total and still be one hard run block away from trouble.

We also hold a simple floor. If your bike fitness is under 45, or your run fitness is under 35, on the chronic training load scale TrainingPeaks uses, that sport starts in Base and Durability. That holds whatever your race calendar says. The reason is tissue as much as fitness. Harder work asks more of joints, tendons and muscles, and a sport below the floor hasn't built the base to carry it. Skipping the base doesn't save time. It moves the cost to later in the season, when it is harder to absorb.
That floor shaped the plans for two of our athletes this fall.
Graham's bike and run fitness against the floor
What it measures. Graham Lloyd's fitness on the bike and on the run on September 1 and October 31, 2026, against the floor for each sport.
The story at this point. Graham came to ANC strong on the bike and rebuilding his running. His log from February to May was swimming, riding and long walks. On September 1, just before the IRONMAN 70.3 World Championship in Nice, his bike fitness was 49, above the floor of 45. His run fitness was 19, well under 35. By the end of October, with recovery after Nice and no race booked, both had come down.
How to read it. The tall bars on the left are the bike, and the short bars on the right are the run. The orange lines are the floors. A bar under its line means that sport starts its next block in Base and Durability.
You might see this in your own training if one of your sports feels strong and the other feels like it is always catching up. The weaker sport usually needs its own block.

Graham's run couldn't be judged by a test in June, because you can't test a run you aren't doing yet. So we evaluated it with three things: his heart rate, the pace on his watch, and how his legs felt in the first mile and a half. He told us his legs were stiff at the start of every session and loosened around that point. Angela called that good data, and it became a signal we used for months. The floor told us how to pace his race in Nice and what to build after it. His run stayed in Base and Durability, by design.
Ben's fitness against the floor after his marathon
What it measures. Ben Creswick's bike and run fitness on October 30, 2026, three weeks after the Victoria Marathon, against the floor for each sport.
The story at this point. Ben raced IRONMAN 70.3 Tri Cities on September 20 and the Victoria Marathon on October 11. After Tri Cities his run stayed race specific while his bike went back to base work, because he had no bike race for eight months. A month of run focus left his run fitness at 54, well above its floor. His bike fitness was 43, just under 45.
How to read it. The navy bar is the bike and the orange bar is the run. The teal lines are the floors. The bike bar sits just under its line. The run bar is well above.
You might see this in your own training if you just finished a season that leaned hard on one sport. The other sport may need rebuilding before it is ready for harder work.

The floor was one of three reasons Ben is in Base and Durability in both sports now. His next A race, IRONMAN 70.3 Victoria on May 30, 2027, is about 30 weeks away, which is the time to build an engine. His marathon showed us that long range durability is the thing to build next. The numbers, the calendar and the race all pointed the same way, and when three separate inputs agree we can commit to a block with confidence.
What your comments tell us that numbers can't
Numbers show what you did. Your comments tell us what it cost and why. Two weeks can look identical in TrainingPeaks and mean opposite things, and the comment is often the only way to tell them apart.
Ben is a clear example. On his first runs after a week off, his heart rate sat higher than usual. Read alone, that number could suggest lost fitness or building fatigue, and either reading would have changed his plan. His comments told us he felt fine and was simply getting going again. Angela wrote back: "HR sitting a little higher after a week off is totally normal. It should settle back down over the next few runs." It did, and the plan stayed on course.
Some comments tell us about the athlete. Graham's notes on his early walk run sessions were careful and detailed. After his first one he wrote: "Body's initial reaction was hey what's this? It tensed up for the first half a mile, but after that, it gradually relaxed." An athlete who notices that much can be trusted to read his own legs, and the coaching gave him room to do it.
Some comments tell us about the week. Katy Walmsley trains around three kids, school runs and basketball games. Her log has lines like "I have to get kids to early events today so pre dawn was my window." That tells us which days are fixed, which are flexible and where the risk of a missed session sits, which is exactly what we need to place the key sessions where they will happen.
Readiness: telling useful tiredness from too much
Training is meant to make you tired. The question every week is whether the tiredness is the kind that turns into fitness, or the kind that turns into a missed week. They can feel the same to the athlete and look similar in a single number, so we read several things together.

We look at how your completed sessions compared with the plan, what you wrote in your comments and messages, and your heart rate variability and resting heart rate if you track them. Signs that fatigue has gone past useful include poor sleep, rising effort for the same work, a resting heart rate that has crept up, very low form, or simply the word "tired" showing up comment after comment. One of these alone is usually noise. Several together are a pattern, and when that pattern shows up midweek we ease the week then and there. Waiting for the planned easy week would mean several more days of load on an athlete who is already past what they can absorb.
Readiness can also be good news. In late October Katy checked in with us over two days, and once her sessions came back on plan her readiness read clear on every marker we track. That let us move her carefully toward a Hybrid block for La Quinta 70.3 on December 6. Careful was the right word. Good numbers never override a poor position to absorb more, and one good week is a reason to proceed slowly. Anything about how your body is holding up goes to Angela, every time, and she decides those calls herself.
Evaluation in the middle of a build
Learning where you are is easiest to see at the start of a season. It is just as important in the middle of one, when the question changes from "where are you?" to "is this working?"
Katy's run fitness, fatigue and form at five points in her Boston build
What it measures. Katy's run fitness, run fatigue and run form on five dates from December 2025 to Boston on April 20, 2026. Form is fitness minus fatigue. Above zero means fresher than usual.
The story at this point. Katy came to ANC wanting to make her running hours count. She is a triathlete, so she kept riding and swimming, and the bike and pool carried much of her aerobic work. Each snapshot is a moment we stopped and asked what the training was doing. In January, as she stepped from base into her first bigger block, fitness and fatigue met. Through February and March her run fitness held around 50 while she raised the quality of her running. By race morning her fatigue had dropped well below her fitness.
How to read it. Navy is fitness, grey is fatigue and orange is form. Look at the gap between the navy and grey bars. On April 20 it is the widest of the build, which is why her form reached about plus 23 on race morning.
You might see this in your own training if your run fitness has felt stuck even while your training got better. Steady run fitness can still carry much better running when the rest of the week supports it.

Katy's run fitness holding steady through February and March could have been read as a plateau. Read with her sessions and comments, it meant something else: the quality of her running was rising while the bike and pool carried aerobic load. Three weeks before Boston she ran a half marathon best of 1:34:09, and at Boston she ran 3:28:46, a marathon PR. In January the question was whether she could handle a bigger block. In March it was whether her ceiling needed raising. In April it was whether she was fresh enough. Each answer came from her numbers, her comments and her calendar read together.
Evaluation after a race
A race is the most useful test there is, and we evaluate every one. We look at what worked, what we would change and what we should celebrate. Then we look again at the calendar and redefine the block.

After his marathon, Ben's race told us what his run can hold for hours, and it shaped his winter. After Nice, Graham's numbers and the floor sent his run back to Base and Durability, and his walk run ladder kept climbing inside that block. On October 11 he ran what he called his "fastest 5k since June 2018 which was in a race." Each athlete got a different next step, because each evaluation found something different.
How the evaluation changes the decision
The same inputs lead to different calls depending on what they show together. These are situations we see often.
Your intake says 12 hours a week and your history says 7
We start from the 7. The plan grows from the training your body has actually absorbed.
One sport is above its floor and the other is below
Each sport gets its own block. The sport below the floor starts in Base and Durability, as Graham's run and Ben's bike did this fall.
A number looks off and your comment says you feel fine
We read them together and usually wait a few sessions before changing anything, as we did with Ben's heart rate after a week off.
Your numbers look good and your comments say tired, short on sleep, stressed at work
We hold or ease the week. Good numbers never override a poor position to absorb more.
What evaluation needs from you
Evaluation is only as good as what we can see. That asks two things of you. The first is your real week: the actual hours you have, the days that are fixed and the ones that aren't, and the training you have really been doing. The second is honest comments. If every session is written up as fine when it isn't, we are evaluating an athlete who isn't there.
Here is the short version of what goes into each weekly evaluation.
- Your fitness, by sport. Is it rising, holding or falling, and is it above the floor?
- Your fatigue and form. How tired are you compared with your normal, and which way has it been moving over the last five days?
- Your completed sessions. Did you do what was planned, and how did you execute it?
- Your comments and messages. What did each session cost, and what is happening at work and at home?
- Your recovery signals. Sleep, resting heart rate, heart rate variability, soreness and mood.
- Your calendar. How far away your next important race is, and what is coming up in your life.
None of these decides alone. A great week of numbers with poor sleep and a sore calf is a week to hold. A tired week after a planned push is often exactly what we wanted.
What this means for you
What this means for you
When you start with us, the first thing we do is listen and look. The more we know about your real week, your real history and how sessions actually feel, the better each decision gets. Evaluation never stops. Every week we ask where you are now and let the answer shape the next week.
A good check for your own training: could you say, right now, which of your sports is strongest and which is most fragile, and what your last six weeks really averaged? If not, that is where evaluation starts.
Keep reading in the How We Coach series
- StressLogic in four steps
- Part 3: Setting your Critical Power and Critical Speed
- Part 4: Fitting training to life
- Load and recovery
Athlete stories from this article:
Coaching built around you
If you would like your training to start from where you really are, start at angelanaethcoaching.com.
Tell us your goal race and the hours you really have. Or see our online IRONMAN coaching.
