Playbook · Zones
Zones without a power meter
Pace, heart rate and feel, set from one test you can do this week. No gadgets required.
By Angela Naeth
In this article
The problem
Why we test instead of guessing
Most watches hand you heart rate zones from a formula built on your age. 220 minus your age has nothing to do with your heart, and two athletes the same age can have maximum heart rates 30 beats apart. Pace zones from a race you ran two years ago are not much better. Training in zones that are wrong is worse than not using zones at all, because it makes the easy days too hard and the hard days too easy.
So we test. Every athlete we coach, whatever the sport, gets zones from a measured effort on their own body, done this month. It takes one session.
The number
What Critical Speed is
Critical Speed is the fastest pace you can hold in a steady state, where your body is clearing what it produces as fast as it produces it. Run faster than it and you are on a clock that runs out in minutes. Run slower and you can go for a very long time. It sits close to the pace you could race for about 40 to 60 minutes.
It is the same idea as Critical Power on the bike, and it is why we never use FTP or a single 20 minute test. Two efforts of different lengths let us draw a line through them and find the real sustainable pace, plus a second number, D prime, that tells us how much you can do above it. For most athletes, Critical Speed alone sets the zones.
Do this
The test
A track is best. A flat, measured loop or a known flat road works. Flat is the point. Pick a day when you are rested, cool weather if you can, and no hard session the day before.
- Warm up 15 minutes easy, with a few drills and three 20 second pickups.
- 800 metres all out. Two laps. Pace it even, not a sprint and a fade. Record the time.
- Walk and jog 8 to 10 minutes. Fully recover.
- 3,200 metres all out. Eight laps, even paced. The first lap should feel too easy. Record the time.
- Cool down 10 minutes and write down both times and the average heart rate for each.
Send us the numbers if you are an ANC or club athlete and a coach sends back your Critical Speed and zones. If you want to do it yourself, the maths is simple: Critical Speed equals the difference in distance divided by the difference in time. 2,400 metres divided by the seconds between the two efforts gives metres per second. Turn that into pace per mile or per kilometre and that is your number.
The maths
Worked example
800 m in 3:20 (200 seconds). 3,200 m in 15:40 (940 seconds). Difference: 2,400 m in 740 s, which is 3.24 m/s. That is 8:17 per mile, or 5:09 per km. That is Critical Speed. The zones below come off it.
Your zones
Your zones from the result
We use percentages of Critical Speed for pace. Here they are for the 8:17 athlete above. Slide the numbers for your own.
| Zone | % of CS | Pace (example) | What it feels like |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recovery (ZR) | under 70% | slower than 11:50 | Jogging. Nearly embarrassing. |
| Zone 1, easy aerobic | 70 to 84% | 9:50 to 11:50 | Most of your running. Full sentences. |
| Zone 2, steady | 85 to 92% | 9:00 to 9:45 | Long run finishes, IRONMAN run pace for many. |
| Zone 3, tempo | 93 to 97% | 8:30 to 8:55 | Half marathon to 70.3 run effort. |
| Zone 4, threshold | 98 to 103% | 8:00 to 8:25 | Critical Speed itself. 10K effort. |
| Zone 5, VO2 | 104 to 112% | 7:25 to 7:55 | 3 to 5 minute intervals. 5K and faster. |
Notice how slow Zone 1 is. That is the zone that athletes skip and the one that builds the engine. Eight in ten of your runs live there.
The second number
Adding heart rate
Heart rate is not where we start, because it lags, it drifts in the heat, and it is affected by sleep, caffeine and stress. It is a great second check once pace zones exist. The method we use:
- Run 40 to 60 minutes at the top of your Zone 1 pace on a flat route, in normal conditions.
- Your average heart rate for that run is your Zone 1 heart rate ceiling. Write it down.
- From race data, if you have it: IRONMAN average heart rate sits about 2 beats above that ceiling, a 70.3 about 2 above the top of Zone 2, an Olympic about 2 above the top of Zone 3.
Now you have a pace and a heart rate for your easy running. When the two disagree, pay attention. Heart rate 8 beats high for your usual easy pace means heat, fatigue, dehydration or the start of a cold. Slow down to the heart rate, not the pace. On hills, in heat, or when you are tired, heart rate and feel lead. On a flat cool day, pace leads.
The third number
Feel: the one you always have
Every session in TrainingPeaks asks how it felt, and we read those answers as closely as we read the numbers. Feel is the number that catches what the watch misses. Use a simple scale and be honest with it.
| Feel | How to tell | Zone |
|---|---|---|
| Easy | Full conversation, nose breathing possible, could go for hours. | Zones R and 1 |
| Steady | Short sentences. Comfortably working. | Zone 2 |
| Hard | A few words at a time. Want it to end in 20 minutes. | Zones 3 and 4 |
| Very hard | No talking. Counting down the seconds. | Zone 5 |
If a Zone 1 run feels steady, you are going too fast or you are tired. Both are information. Neither is fixed by pushing on.
On the bike
On the bike without power
If you ride without a power meter, use heart rate and feel, and borrow the structure. Do a steady 40 to 60 minute ride at an effort where you can talk in full sentences and take that heart rate as your bike Zone 1 ceiling. Bike heart rate normally runs 5 to 10 beats lower than run heart rate for the same zone, so do not copy the run numbers across.
For quality sessions, use feel and time: 3 x 10 minutes at a hard but repeatable effort, where the third one feels the same as the first. An indoor trainer with a speed sensor gives you a repeatable number too. When you want a bike power meter, a single-sided crank is enough and a Critical Power test (3 minutes and 12 minutes all out) gives you the bike version of everything above. Our club partner discounts cover that.
Keep it current
When to retest
Zones are not permanent. Retest when a training block ends, usually every 4 to 6 weeks in a build, and any time your easy pace at the same heart rate has moved by more than 15 seconds a mile. Faster is good news and means your zones are now too easy. Slower, for more than a week, is a sign to look at sleep, fueling and stress before anything else.
A test is a training session. It does not need to be perfect. It needs to be honest and repeatable, on the same course, in similar conditions, so the comparison means something.
Do this this week
Three things, nothing else.
- Do the 800 and 3,200 test this week on a rested day. Record both times and the heart rates.
- Work out your Critical Speed and write your six pace zones on a card. Or send the numbers to a coach.
- Run every easy session this week in Zone 1 pace and note the heart rate. That is your baseline for the winter.
Questions we get
I don't have a track.
Any flat measured route works. Use a running watch's GPS lap at 800 and 3,200, or a known road loop. The key is flat and the same place every time.
Can I use a recent race instead?
A flat 5K and a flat 10K within a month of each other work as the two efforts. A hilly race or a hot one will not.
Do I need both heart rate and pace?
Pace alone will get you through the winter. Heart rate adds a safety check on hot days and tired days. Feel you always have.
Keep learning
Related reading
- How we build your week Where the zones go once you have them.
- Run-walk, negative splits and starting slow Using the zones on race day.
- How We Coach Why we never use FTP.
